Short answer. In a family violence case, the person who called the police does not decide whether the case goes forward. The prosecutor does. Many Texas prosecutors’ offices will continue even when the complaining witness asks them to stop.
What is a “no drop” policy?
It is not a statute. It is a practice. The case is styled The State of Texas v. the accused, and the complaining witness is a witness, not a party. Prosecutors adopted the practice because they believe some witnesses recant out of fear or pressure. Sometimes that is true. Sometimes the first account was the inaccurate one, given in anger at two in the morning. The policy does not distinguish between the two, and that is the problem with it.
She signed an affidavit of non-prosecution. Is the case over?
No. The affidavit tells the prosecutor what the witness wants. It does not bind anyone. It can help in negotiations, and it can hurt if it reads as though someone told her what to say.
Can the State really proceed without the complaining witness?
It can try. Prosecutors build these cases to survive without her: the 911 recording, body camera video, photographs, medical records, and the officers who responded. Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 38.371 also lets each side offer evidence about the nature of the relationship, subject to the Rules of Evidence.
The Constitution limits how far that goes. Under Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004), a testimonial statement from a witness who does not appear is generally inadmissible unless she is unavailable and the defense had a prior opportunity to cross-examine her. Under Davis v. Washington, 547 U.S. 813 (2006), statements made to get help during an emergency are treated differently from statements made to an officer once things are calm. A case built on a recorded statement and no live witness is often weaker than the prosecutor’s file makes it look. I explain the rule in The Right to Confrontation in Texas Criminal Trials.
What is the worst thing I can do?
Contact her about the case. Bond conditions and emergency protective orders usually forbid contact, and violating them is a new charge. Worse, if a judge finds that you wrongfully caused her not to appear, you forfeit the right to object to her out-of-court statements. Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 38.49. The State could not use those statements before. Now it can.
What should I do instead?
Hire a lawyer before the first setting. Follow every bond condition to the letter. Let your lawyer be the one who communicates, lawfully, with the prosecutor and, where appropriate, with the witness’s own lawyer.
Frequently asked questions
Can she be forced to testify? She can be subpoenaed, and a subpoena is a court order. What happens after that is a question for her own lawyer.
Does she need her own lawyer? If she is thinking about changing her account, yes. I represent the accused and cannot advise her.
Will a family violence finding follow me? It can affect firearm rights, future charges, and record sealing. See Charged with Assault Family Violence in Bexar County.
Can the judge dismiss the case if she asks? Dismissal starts with the prosecutor. The judge does not dismiss because a witness asks.
How long do these cases take? Months, usually. The State’s willingness to dismiss often changes as trial gets close and its proof problems become real.
If you are charged with family violence in Bexar County, call me at 210-663-3750 before you speak to anyone else about the case.
