Short answer. The State cannot convict you on the word of a witness you never get to cross-examine. That is the rule. The exceptions are where cases are won and lost.
What is the right to confrontation?
The Sixth Amendment gives every accused person the right to be confronted with the witnesses against him. The Texas Constitution says the same in article I, § 10. In plain terms: if someone accuses you, that person has to come to court, take the oath, and answer my questions in front of the jury.
Cross-examination is not a courtesy. It is how a jury learns that a witness was drunk, or angry, or standing sixty feet away in the dark. A written statement cannot be asked a single question.
What changed with Crawford?
For years, courts let prosecutors use an absent witness’s statement if a judge found it “reliable.” In Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36 (2004), the Supreme Court ended that. A testimonial statement from a witness who does not appear is admissible only if the witness is unavailable and the defendant had an earlier chance to cross-examine.
What counts as “testimonial”?
This is the fight in most cases. In Davis v. Washington, 547 U.S. 813 (2006), the Court drew the line by purpose. A 911 caller describing an emergency as it happens is seeking help, and those statements are generally not testimonial. A statement given to an officer after the danger has passed, describing what happened earlier, is testimonial.
So I listen to the 911 recording with a stopwatch. There is usually a moment where the call stops being a cry for help and becomes an interview. Everything after that moment is contestable.
Does it apply to lab reports?
Yes. In Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts, 557 U.S. 305 (2009), the Court held that a forensic analyst’s certificate is testimonial. The State cannot hand the jury a lab report in place of a witness unless the defense agrees.
What exceptions do prosecutors use?
The largest is forfeiture by wrongdoing. A defendant who wrongfully causes a witness to be unavailable loses the right to object to that witness’s statements. Texas codified the rule in Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 38.49, and the judge decides the question outside the jury’s presence by a preponderance of the evidence. The Supreme Court limited the doctrine in Giles v. California, 554 U.S. 353 (2008): the defendant must have acted with the purpose of keeping the witness from testifying.
This is why I tell every client the same thing. Do not contact the complaining witness. A phone call from the jail asking someone not to come to court can hand the State the very statements the Constitution would have kept out.
Why does this matter most in family violence cases?
Because those are the cases where the complaining witness most often does not appear, and the State tries to proceed anyway. I cover that in Can Domestic Violence Charges Be Dropped in Texas?.
Frequently asked questions
Can the State use a 911 call if the caller does not testify? Often part of it. The portion describing an ongoing emergency usually comes in. The rest is open to challenge.
What about body camera statements? It depends on what was happening when they were made. An officer calming a scene is different from an officer taking a statement.
Can a witness testify by video? Only in narrow circumstances, and the defense can object.
Do I waive the right if I do not object? Usually, yes. Confrontation objections must be made at trial, on time, or they are lost on appeal.
Does confrontation apply at a bond hearing? It is a trial right. Different rules govern pretrial hearings.
If the case against you rests on statements from someone who may not testify, call me at 210-663-3750.
