The short answer. Sometimes, yes. Not every investigation ends in charges, and the ones that do are shaped by decisions made in the weeks before anyone is arrested. A lawyer who gets involved early can sometimes keep a case from being filed, get it no-billed by the grand jury, get the charge reduced, or at the very least arrange a surrender so you are not arrested at work. No honest lawyer will promise you any of those. But the time before charges is when the most can be done, and most people spend it waiting.
How do you know you are under investigation?
- A detective left a card or called and said he “just wants to hear your side.”
- Police searched your home or car, or took your phone.
- CPS contacted your family about an accusation.
- Friends, coworkers or relatives tell you a detective has interviewed them.
- Your employer tells you police asked for your records.
If any of that has happened, assume the investigation is real and that it is moving.
Why the weeks before charges matter
A felony charge is a decision made by people reading a file. Police bring the case to the District Attorney’s Office. A prosecutor decides whether the case is strong enough and what to charge. Then a grand jury hears it, and nine of the twelve grand jurors must agree before there is an indictment. You can read how that works in my guide to the Bexar County grand jury.
At every one of those steps, the people deciding usually see only what the detective chose to collect. I know this because I used to read those files. I was Chief of the Criminal Trial Division and Chief of Major Crimes at the Bexar County District Attorney’s Office. A file is a story told by one side. A prosecutor who never hears the rest has no reason to go looking for it.
What a lawyer can do before charges are filed
- Take over all contact with police. The detective calls me, not you.
- Find and keep the evidence that helps you before it disappears: messages, video, receipts, location data, and the names of people who saw what happened.
- Put an investigator on it to talk to the witnesses the detective skipped.
- In the right case, bring that evidence to the prosecutor before the charging decision, or ask that the grand jury be given a written submission. Sometimes that changes the decision. Sometimes it does not, and the smarter move is to say nothing and save the defense for trial. Knowing which case is which is the judgment you are paying for.
- If charges are coming anyway, arrange a surrender on a bond set ahead of time, so you walk in with your lawyer instead of being arrested in front of your family or your boss.
What not to do
Do not talk to the detective without a lawyer
Not even if you are innocent. Not even if he says this is your only chance to tell your side. The interview is not for your benefit. It is how the State locks in your words before it decides what to charge.
Staying quiet is not enough. Say it out loud.
If you are questioned before you are arrested, say plainly that you are invoking your right to remain silent and that you want a lawyer. In Salinas v. Texas, 570 U.S. 178 (2013), a man went to a Houston police station voluntarily, answered questions, and then went silent when asked about the shotgun shells. Because he never said he was invoking his rights, the prosecutor was allowed to use that silence against him at trial (plurality opinion). Silence without the words can be used as evidence.
Do not delete anything
Texts, photos, social media accounts, call logs: leave them alone. Under Texas Penal Code § 37.09, destroying or hiding evidence is a crime if you know an investigation is under way, and it can be a crime even before an investigation if you know an offense was committed. Deleting looks like guilt, and it can become a separate felony.
Do not contact the accuser or the witnesses
The urge to clear things up is human, and it is dangerous. Trying to influence a witness can be charged as tampering with a witness under Penal Code § 36.05, and even an innocent conversation hands the State its best exhibit.
Do not post about it
Anything you write online about the accusation will be read by the detective before it is read by anyone else.
What I will not promise
No lawyer can guarantee that a case will not be filed. Some investigations end in charges no matter what anyone does. What early work does is change what the people deciding get to see before they decide. Sometimes that is enough. When it is not, you start the case with the evidence preserved, the witnesses found, and a lawyer who already knows the file.
If a detective has called you or someone you love, call me before you call him back: 210-663-3750. I answer my own phone, and the consultation is free.
Related reading: police want to question you or your son about a sex offense, the Bexar County grand jury, the first 48 hours after a felony arrest, my years as a prosecutor, and how my fees work.
