Most people charged with robbery in Texas did not set out to rob anyone. They set out to take a phone charger from a store shelf, or a purse from a car seat, and something happened between the shelf and the parking lot. A shove at the door. A loss-prevention employee who grabbed an arm. A word said in a raised voice. By the time the police report is written, a theft case worth a few hundred dollars has become a second-degree felony.
That is the first thing to understand about robbery here: it is not a more serious kind of theft. It is an assault, or a threat, attached to a theft. And the line between robbery and aggravated robbery, which is the line between a probation-eligible case and one where a judge cannot give probation at all, is often drawn by facts the accused barely thought about.
What the State has to prove for robbery
Under Texas Penal Code section 29.02, the State must prove that a person, while committing theft and intending to keep control of the property, either caused bodily injury to someone, or intentionally or knowingly threatened someone or placed them in fear of imminent bodily injury or death. Robbery is a second-degree felony, punishable by 2 to 20 years in prison.
Two parts of that definition do most of the damage.
The first is “in the course of committing theft.” Section 29.01 says that phrase covers an attempt, the theft itself, and “immediate flight” afterward. So the theft can be over. The property can be in your pocket. If the injury or the threat happens while you are leaving, the law treats it as part of the robbery. That is how a shoplifting case becomes a robbery case at the exit.
The second is “bodily injury.” In Texas that means physical pain, illness, or any impairment of physical condition. It is a low bar. A complaining witness who says a push hurt has described bodily injury.
The threat version is just as broad. The State does not have to prove a weapon, or even words. It has to prove that you intentionally or knowingly put someone in fear of imminent injury. Demeanor, size, a step toward someone, a hand in a jacket: prosecutors argue all of these.
What makes it aggravated robbery
Section 29.03 turns robbery into aggravated robbery, a first-degree felony carrying 5 to 99 years or life, if the person:
- causes serious bodily injury;
- uses or exhibits a deadly weapon; or
- causes bodily injury to, threatens, or places in fear someone who is 65 or older or who is a disabled person.
Read the third item again. Nothing about the conduct changes. A shove that is a second-degree felony against a 40-year-old store clerk becomes a first-degree felony against a 66-year-old one.
The deadly weapon element is where I see the most misunderstanding. A gun is a deadly weapon. But under Penal Code section 1.07(a)(17), so is anything that, in the way it was used or intended to be used, is capable of causing death or serious bodily injury. A screwdriver, a bottle, a vehicle, a pocketknife.
And “uses or exhibits” does not require that the weapon was pointed at anyone. In McCain v. State, 22 S.W.3d 497 (Tex. Crim. App. 2000), the man never touched or mentioned the butcher knife in his back pocket. The complainant saw part of it sticking out during the assault. The Court of Criminal Appeals held that was enough. A jury could infer that the visible knife made her afraid to resist, and “use” includes even simple possession when the possession facilitates the crime. Possession alone, with nothing connecting it to the offense, is not enough. But that connection is a question for the jury, and juries are not hard to persuade about a knife. People hear “armed robbery” and picture a gun pointed at a cashier. The law reaches much further than that picture.
Why the difference matters so much
Aggravated robbery is on the list in Code of Criminal Procedure article 42A.054(a), often called the “3g” list. That has two consequences.
First, a judge cannot place someone convicted of aggravated robbery on community supervision. A jury can recommend probation, but only if it assesses 10 years or less (article 42A.056). That makes the choice between judge and jury sentencing one of the most important decisions in the case.
Second, if the person goes to prison, Government Code section 508.145(d) delays parole eligibility until actual time served equals half the sentence, or 30 years, whichever is less, and never less than two years. Good-conduct time does not count toward that. On a 20-year sentence, that is 10 calendar years before the parole board can even consider release.
A plain robbery conviction can carry the same treatment if the judgment includes an affirmative deadly weapon finding. So even when the charge is “only” robbery, whether the State alleges a deadly weapon matters.
Where these cases are actually fought
I was a prosecutor before I was a defense lawyer, and I can tell you where these cases are weakest from the State’s side of the table.
Identification. Robberies happen fast, often at night, often between strangers, and the witness’s attention goes to the weapon or the hands, not the face. How the police showed the witness a photo lineup, what the witness said before seeing it, and how certain the witness was the first time all matter.
The timeline of the force. If the property was abandoned before anyone was touched, or the struggle came after the person had already given up the theft, the State may not be able to connect the force to the theft. That can be the difference between robbery and a theft plus a misdemeanor assault.
What the “weapon” really was. A dark object in a hand, a shape under a shirt. Video often tells a different story than a frightened witness does, and it disappears fast. Store systems overwrite footage in days or weeks.
Age and disability. When the State relies on the complainant’s age or disability to aggravate the case, it has to prove it. “Disabled person” has a specific definition in section 29.03(c): someone with a mental, physical, or developmental disability who is substantially unable to protect himself from harm. That is not the same as being frail or elderly.
What to do now
If you or someone in your family has been charged or is being looked at for robbery in Bexar County, do not explain your side to the detective, the store, or the complaining witness. Everything said in those conversations ends up in the file. Write down what you remember about where you were and who was with you, and have a lawyer move to preserve video before it is gone.
If someone is already in jail on an aggravated robbery charge, I wrote separately about bail for aggravated robbery in Bexar County. More on how I defend these cases is on my robbery and aggravated robbery defense page.
The words on the charging document were chosen by someone who heard one side. Whether the case stays a robbery, gets reduced, or goes away usually depends on what gets found in the first weeks.
Frequently asked questions
Is robbery a felony in Texas?
Yes. Robbery is a second-degree felony with a range of 2 to 20 years. Aggravated robbery is a first-degree felony with a range of 5 to 99 years or life.
Can shoplifting become robbery?
Yes. If a person causes bodily injury or threatens someone while committing theft or in “immediate flight” afterward, the case can be charged as robbery under Penal Code section 29.02, no matter how little the property was worth.
Does aggravated robbery require a gun?
No. Any object that is capable of causing death or serious bodily injury in the way it is used or intended to be used can be a deadly weapon, and the Court of Criminal Appeals has held that a weapon can be “used” without being pointed at anyone. A robbery can also be aggravated without any weapon if the complainant is 65 or older or disabled, or suffers serious bodily injury.
Can you get probation for aggravated robbery in Texas?
Not from a judge. Article 42A.054 bars judge-ordered community supervision for aggravated robbery. A jury can recommend probation if it sets punishment at 10 years or less.
How much time do you have to serve on an aggravated robbery sentence before parole?
Half of the sentence in actual calendar time, or 30 years, whichever is less, and at least two years. Good-conduct time does not reduce that.
Can an aggravated robbery charge be reduced to robbery?
It can, when the evidence of the aggravating element is weak, for example when the “weapon” is unclear, the injury was not serious, or the complainant’s age or disability is not proven. Whether that happens depends on the evidence in the specific case.
