By Mario Del Prado, Board Certified in Criminal Law, Texas Board of Legal Specialization. Former Chief of the Criminal Trial Division and Chief of Major Crimes, Bexar County District Attorney’s Office. Licensed in Texas since 1986.
The short answer. Yes. In Texas the person who drove the car can be charged with aggravated robbery, the same first-degree felony as the person who held the gun, and if someone died, the charge can be capital murder. But driving is not the crime. The State has to prove he knew what was going to happen and meant to help it happen. In many of these cases, that is the weakest part of the case against him.
How Texas makes the driver answer for what someone else did
The rule is called the law of parties. A person is guilty of an offense committed by someone else if, “acting with intent to promote or assist the commission of the offense,” he “solicits, encourages, directs, aids, or attempts to aid” the other person. Tex. Penal Code § 7.02(a)(2). Every party can be charged with the offense itself, and the State does not have to say in the indictment whether he was the gunman or the help. § 7.01(b), (c). It is no defense that the person with the gun was never charged, or was acquitted. § 7.03.
So the indictment may say their son “used or exhibited a deadly weapon” when he never touched one. Aggravated robbery is robbery plus one of a few aggravating facts: serious bodily injury, a deadly weapon used or exhibited, or a victim who is 65 or older or disabled. § 29.03(a). It is a first-degree felony, five years to life. §§ 29.03(b), 12.32(a). The driver faces the whole range.
What the prosecutor needs, and often does not have
I ran the Criminal Trial and Major Crimes divisions at the Bexar County DA’s Office. A driver case usually reaches the prosecutor resting on proximity. His car is on the gas station video. His phone hit a tower near the store. He was behind the wheel when police stopped the car twenty minutes later. All of that proves where he was. None of it proves what he knew.
The Court of Criminal Appeals has said so plainly. Mere presence at the scene, “or even flight from the scene, without more,” is not enough to convict someone as a party. Gross v. State, 380 S.W.3d 181, 186 (Tex. Crim. App. 2012). In Gross, the State pointed to the defendant’s presence, his role as the getaway driver, and his denial to police. The court held that his conduct after the shooting might support a charge of hindering apprehension, but that the evidence was legally insufficient to make him a party to the murder, because nothing showed a plan made before or during the shooting. Id. at 186–88. Courts look at what happened before, during and after the offense, but there has to be evidence of an understanding and a common design. Id. at 186.
That is where a driver’s case is won or lost. Did he know there was a gun in the car? Did he know the stop was a robbery, or was he told they were picking something up? Who chose the place? What did the group text say that afternoon? Did he get a share of anything? What did he do when it went wrong: drive off, or sit frozen in the lot?
When the robbery goes wrong: the conspiracy rule
There is a second, harsher path. Under § 7.02(b), if people agree to commit one felony and one of them commits another felony while carrying it out, all of them are guilty of the felony actually committed, “though having no intent to commit it,” if it was done in furtherance of the plan and “should have been anticipated.”
Capital murder in Texas includes an intentional killing in the course of a robbery. § 19.03(a)(2). Put that next to § 7.02(b), and a young man who agreed to drive for what he thought was a robbery can be charged with capital murder for a shooting he never wanted. If the State does not seek death, the sentence for a person who was 18 or older is life without parole. If he was younger than 18, it is life. § 12.31(a).
The defense to that charge is in the statute’s own words. Was there an agreement to commit a felony at all, or only a ride? Was the killing in furtherance of that plan? Should a death have been anticipated by someone who may not have known a gun was in the car? I have written separately about how the State builds a murder case in Bexar County, and the parties theory is often the joint where it comes apart.
The co-defendant who talks first
These cases almost always have more than one person in them, and somebody usually cooperates. Very often the one who talks is the one who planned it or pulled the trigger, and his story is that the driver knew everything.
Texas does not let a jury convict on that alone. A conviction “cannot be had upon the testimony of an accomplice unless corroborated by other evidence tending to connect the defendant with the offense,” and corroboration that “merely shows the commission of the offense” is not enough. Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 38.14. In a driver case, proof that the robbery happened is easy. Independent proof that he knew it was coming often is not.
Why the charge on the paperwork matters so much
A judge cannot place a person on community supervision after a conviction for aggravated robbery. Tex. Code Crim. Proc. art. 42A.054(a)(11). The same limit applies when a deadly weapon was used or exhibited in a felony, but for someone who was only a party, the law requires proof that he “knew that a deadly weapon would be used or exhibited.” Art. 42A.054(b)(2)(B).
That knowledge question comes back again and again. It is the difference between aggravated robbery and robbery, a second-degree felony (Tex. Penal Code § 29.02(b)), and between a case where the judge has no probation option and one where the judge may have one. I make no promise about any outcome; every case turns on its own facts. But the fight over what the driver knew shapes every offer that follows.
What to do this week
- Do not let him “explain that he was just the driver.” That explanation is the statement prosecutors want most. “I knew he had a gun, but I didn’t think he’d use it” sounds like innocence to a parent. To a prosecutor it is the knowledge element, in his own voice.
- Assume every jail call is recorded. Do not discuss the facts on the phone or on video visits.
- Delete nothing. Not texts, not social media, not the group chat. Deleting can create a new charge, and it looks like guilt.
- Write down what you know for his lawyer only: who picked him up, what he was told, who he called that day.
- Deal with bond early. Bond on aggravated robbery is often set high. Here is how bail works for aggravated robbery in Bexar County.
More on the charge itself: aggravated robbery defense in San Antonio.
The car proves less than it seems
The State’s case against a driver is a story about what was in his head. The car is its best evidence and its weakest. It puts him at the scene, and it says nothing about what he knew when he turned the key. The best defense work happens in that gap, and it starts before he gives the State anything to fill it.
If your son or someone in your family has been charged as the driver in a robbery in Bexar, Guadalupe or a surrounding county, call me at 210-663-3750. My office is at 342 W. Woodlawn Ave., Suite 302, San Antonio. I take these calls myself.
Questions families ask about driver and party cases
Can the driver get the same sentence as the person with the gun?
Legally, yes. A party is charged with the same offense and faces the same punishment range. The judge or jury may consider his actual role when deciding punishment, but the range does not shrink because he stayed in the car.
Is being in the car during a robbery a crime by itself?
No. Texas’s highest criminal court has held that mere presence at the scene, even together with flight, is not enough to convict someone as a party. The State must prove he intended to promote or assist the offense. Gross v. State, 380 S.W.3d 181 (Tex. Crim. App. 2012).
Can my son be charged with capital murder if someone else did the shooting?
Yes, in some cases. Under Texas Penal Code § 7.02(b), if people agree to commit a felony such as robbery and one of them commits another felony while carrying it out, all of them can be guilty of it if it was in furtherance of the plan and should have been anticipated. If the State does not seek death, capital murder carries life without parole for someone who was 18 or older.
Can he be convicted just because a co-defendant says he knew?
Not on that testimony alone. Texas Code of Criminal Procedure article 38.14 requires other evidence tending to connect the accused to the offense, and evidence that only shows the robbery happened is not enough.
Can a judge give probation for aggravated robbery?
Not after a conviction for aggravated robbery. Texas Code of Criminal Procedure article 42A.054 takes that option away from the judge. Whether the case ends as aggravated robbery, robbery or something else is one reason the fight over what the driver knew matters so much.
He only helped afterward. Is that the same crime?
Not necessarily. Help given only after the offense is over does not by itself make someone a party to it, though it can be charged separately, for example as hindering apprehension or prosecution under Texas Penal Code § 38.05, which is usually a far less serious offense.
