On November 19, 2026, KSAT 12 courthouse reporter Erica Hernandez asked me about the death penalty in Bexar County. The news peg was grim: three Texas executions set for 2027, two of them from Bexar County cases. Her full story is here: Three Texas executions scheduled for 2027 include two cases from Bexar County.

I have seen capital cases from both tables. I was on the prosecution team that tried Otis McKane for the murder of San Antonio police Detective Benjamin Marconi, and in 2021 that jury returned the most recent death sentence in Bexar County. Today I defend people charged with capital murder. A television segment has room for two or three sentences. Here is the rest of what I think.

Seeking death is a choice, and it should be a hard one

In Texas the prosecutor decides whether to seek the death penalty. If the State does not seek it, an adult convicted of capital murder is sentenced to life without parole. Nobody else makes that call: not the judge, not the jury, not the victim’s family.

What I told KSAT is what I believed as a prosecutor and still believe. I would not take the death penalty off the table, but I would not seek it casually either, because it takes enormous manpower and a great deal of money.

Money sounds like the least noble reason to be careful. It is not. A death case is two trials in one. After a guilty verdict, Article 37.071 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requires a separate sentencing trial before the same jury, where both sides present evidence about the defendant’s whole life. That means a mitigation investigation reaching back to childhood, expert witnesses on both sides, months of jury selection, and an automatic appeal to the Court of Criminal Appeals. Every hour a prosecutor’s office spends there is an hour not spent on other cases. Seeking death in the wrong case does not make a community safer. It makes everything else slower.

The deeper reason for care is the one nobody can fix afterward. A wrongful conviction in a life case can be corrected. A wrongful execution cannot.

What the jury actually decides

Most people picture a jury voting “death” or “life.” Texas jurors do something more specific. They answer questions.

The first is whether there is a probability that the defendant would commit criminal acts of violence that would be a continuing threat to society. The State has to prove that beyond a reasonable doubt, and the jury cannot answer “yes” unless all twelve agree.

If the answer is yes, the jury then decides whether, considering everything, including the defendant’s character, background, and personal moral culpability, there is enough mitigation to warrant life without parole instead of death. A death sentence requires a unanimous “no” to that question. If the jury cannot answer either question, the judge must sentence the defendant to life without parole. The law forbids anyone from telling the jurors that, so each juror goes into deliberations without knowing what happens if they hold out.

Jurors should wrestle with it

Before any of that, the jury has to be chosen, and death-penalty jury selection is unlike any other. Each prospective juror is questioned, usually alone, about whether they could ever impose a death sentence. Under Wainwright v. Witt, 469 U.S. 412 (1985), a juror can be excused for cause if their views about the death penalty would prevent or substantially impair them from following their instructions and their oath.

Here is what surprises people. Some jurors who said in a questionnaire that they could vote for death change their minds once they are sitting in that chair, looking at a real person, after hearing the real evidence. I told KSAT: “A lot of these people are like, I don’t think I can do it. And they should. They should wrestle with that.”

I meant it. A juror who finds the question easy has not understood it. The system depends on twelve people who feel the full weight of what they are being asked to do.

For families facing a capital charge

If someone you love has been charged with capital murder in Bexar County, the most important period is often before the District Attorney decides whether to seek death. That decision is not automatic, and it can turn on information the prosecutors do not yet have about the person charged. Gathering that information takes time, and the defense should start the day the case begins. I wrote about those first days in Capital murder defense in Texas: what families need to know in the first 48 hours, and about what prosecuting a death case taught me in What Prosecuting a Death-Penalty Case Taught Me About Defending One.

KSAT reported that Texas juries sentenced 48 people to death in 1999 and three in 2025. Some read that as the death penalty fading away. I read it differently. Prosecutors are choosing fewer cases, and jurors are taking the question more seriously than they once did. Both of those are what the law asks of them.

Frequently asked questions

Who decides whether to seek the death penalty in Bexar County?

The District Attorney’s Office. If the State does not seek death, an adult convicted of capital murder receives life without parole.

What are the possible sentences when the State seeks death?

Death or life without parole. The jury’s answers to the special issues in Article 37.071 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure decide which.

Does a Texas jury have to be unanimous to impose death?

Yes. Jurors must agree unanimously that the defendant would be a continuing threat to society, and unanimously that there is not enough mitigation to warrant life without parole. If they cannot answer either question, the sentence is life without parole.

Can someone who opposes the death penalty serve on a capital jury?

Opposing the death penalty does not by itself disqualify a juror. Under Wainwright v. Witt, a juror can be excused only if those views would prevent or substantially impair them from following the court’s instructions and their oath.

Can the governor stop an execution in Texas?

Only in a limited way. The Texas Constitution lets the governor grant one reprieve of up to 30 days in a capital case. Commutation and other clemency generally require a recommendation from the Board of Pardons and Paroles.

Call Mario: 210-663-3750