Short answer. An assault charge is a set of elements the State has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense either knocks out an element or justifies the conduct. Which one fits depends on the evidence, not on which one sounds best.

What does the State have to prove?

Under Tex. Penal Code § 22.01(a), a person commits assault by intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly causing bodily injury to another; by intentionally or knowingly threatening another with imminent bodily injury; or by intentionally or knowingly causing physical contact the person knows or should reasonably believe the other will regard as offensive or provocative. Every word in that sentence is something a prosecutor must prove.

1. Self-defense or defense of another

Force is justified when you reasonably believe it is immediately necessary to protect yourself against another’s unlawful force. Tex. Penal Code § 9.31. The same principle covers protecting a third person. Tex. Penal Code § 9.33. Once the evidence raises the issue, the State has to disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt. Saxton v. State, 804 S.W.2d 910 (Tex. Crim. App. 1991). See Texas Self-Defense Laws Explained Simply.

2. No culpable mental state

Accidents are not assaults. If two people collide in a doorway, or a hand flies up in surprise, the State may not be able to prove that the contact was intentional, knowing, or even reckless. Prosecutors tend to assume intent from injury. A jury does not have to.

3. The accusation is not true

Some accusations are false. More are exaggerated, or shaped by a breakup, a custody fight, or alcohol. The work here is unglamorous: phone records, messages sent an hour after the supposed assault, photographs with time stamps, neighbors who heard nothing. A witness’s account is evidence. It is not proof until it survives cross-examination.

4. Consent, or what people call “mutual combat”

Texas has no defense by that name, but it has the idea. The other person’s effective consent, or your reasonable belief that he consented, is a defense to assault if the conduct did not threaten or inflict serious bodily injury. Tex. Penal Code § 22.06. Two men who agree to step outside and settle it have raised a consent question. The defense has limits, and it disappears when the injury is serious.

5. The State cannot carry its burden

This is the defense people underrate. The complaining witness does not appear, or tells a different story than the offense report, or the officer’s body camera contradicts his own report. When the proof is thin I do not need a counter-story. I need the jury to hold the State to its burden.

Frequently asked questions

Is assault a misdemeanor or a felony? It depends on the injury, the relationship between the people, any weapon, and prior convictions. See Assault or Aggravated Assault: How One Word Changes Your Exposure.

The other person started it. Does that matter? It can. It goes to self-defense and to who the jury believes.

Can the complaining witness drop the charges? No. The State decides. See Can Domestic Violence Charges Be Dropped in Texas?.

Should I give the detective my side? Not without a lawyer. Your statement is the easiest evidence the State will ever collect.

Will I have to go to trial? Not necessarily. Many cases end in dismissal or reduction when the weaknesses are shown to the prosecutor early.

If you are charged with assault in San Antonio or Bexar County, call me at 210-663-3750.

Call Mario: 210-663-3750