• The short answer. Check three things you can verify yourself, in this order. One, is the lawyer Board Certified in Criminal Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization. You can look this up free, by name, in about thirty seconds. Two, has the lawyer actually tried cases to a jury verdict in the county where your case is filed. Ask for the number and the counties. Three, will the lawyer you are paying be the lawyer standing next to you. Everything else, including price, comes after those three.

 

People search for the best criminal lawyer in San Antonio at two in the morning, usually because someone they love was arrested that afternoon. I understand the search. I want to give you something more useful than another lawyer telling you he is the answer.

Why no honest lawyer will tell you he is the best

Texas Disciplinary Rule of Professional Conduct 7.01(a) governs what a lawyer may say about his own services. A communication is misleading, in the rule’s words, if “there is a substantial likelihood that it will lead a reasonable person to formulate a specific conclusion about the lawyer or the lawyer’s services for which there is no reasonable factual foundation.” Comment 7 to that rule adds that an unsubstantiated comparison of one lawyer’s services to another’s may be misleading where it is stated specifically enough that a reasonable person would think it could be backed up.

There is no data set that ranks the criminal defense bar of Bexar County. So there is no lawyer in this city with a reasonable factual foundation for telling you he is the best one, and you should treat the claim itself as information about the person making it.

What can be substantiated is narrower and more useful: certification, experience, prior positions held, and the counties and courts where a lawyer actually appears. Ask for those. They are checkable.

Why does board certification matter? Think about your doctor.

If a surgeon were about to operate on your child, you would want to know whether he is board certified. Nobody would call that question rude. A medical license lets a doctor practice medicine. Board certification tells you that other doctors and an examining board have already looked hard at his training and his work in that specialty.

Law works the same way, and almost nobody outside the profession knows it. A Texas law license lets a lawyer take a murder case the week he is sworn in. Nothing stops him. What the State does give you is a way to tell the difference: the Texas Board of Legal Specialization, created by the Supreme Court of Texas, certifies lawyers in criminal law. By the Board’s own count, 762 lawyers in the entire state hold that certification today.

Most lawyers who take criminal cases are not on that list. In my experience the exam is not the main barrier. The trial record a lawyer needs just to be allowed to sit for the exam is.

What does Board Certified in Criminal Law actually require?

Certification in criminal law is not a membership, a listing, or an award anyone can buy. Here is what it takes.

TBLS requirements for certification in criminal law

Requirement Standard
Time in practice At least five years of full-time law practice
Criminal law focus At least 25 percent of the lawyer’s practice devoted to Texas criminal law in each of the three years before applying
Trial record As lead counsel, over the lawyer’s career, the minimum in three of these four: 5 state felony jury trials; 10 misdemeanor jury trials or 5 more felony jury trials; 5 federal jury trials or 10 contested federal matters; 5 state or federal appeals
Continuing education 60 hours of criminal law CLE in the three years before applying
References Five people who practice in or preside over criminal cases: four Texas criminal lawyers, at least one of whom tried a case with or against the applicant, and one Texas judge the applicant has appeared before in a criminal case
Examination A six-hour written examination in criminal law
Recertification Every five years, with the 25 percent standard met in each year, 100 more hours of criminal law CLE, and new references

Source: Texas Board of Legal Specialization, Standards for Attorney Certification, Part I and Specific Area Requirements for Criminal Law.

Look at the trial row. Most criminal cases end in a plea, and a lawyer can keep a busy practice for years on pleas alone. Pleas do not count here. The Board wants to see that a lawyer has stood in front of a jury as lead counsel, again and again, and carried the case himself.

Then look at the references. The Board does not ask the applicant’s friends. It asks lawyers who practice criminal law, at least one of whom has tried a case with or against the applicant, and a judge who has watched him work. People who have seen him in a courtroom are asked whether he knows what he is doing.

Certification is not a guarantee of anything. It is evidence, and evidence beats adjectives. When you are choosing a Board Certified Criminal Lawyer in San Antonio or anywhere in Bexar County, you can verify the certification yourself at tbls.org before you pay anyone a retainer.

The eleven questions

Take these to every consultation, including mine.

What to ask before you hire

Question What a straight answer sounds like
Are you Board Certified in Criminal Law by TBLS? Yes and the year, or no and why the lawyer believes his experience substitutes
How many jury trials have you taken to verdict? How many in Bexar County? Two numbers, said without hesitating
Have you tried a case of this type to a verdict? A straight yes or no. “I’ve handled many” is not an answer to this question
Who will appear at my settings? You, or an associate? A name
Who will answer the phone when I call at night? A name
What is the fee, and what does it cover? A written agreement that says what is included and what is billed separately
Does the fee cover trial, or only up to trial? This is the single most common surprise. Get it in writing
What are the investigator and expert costs likely to be? A range and what triggers them
What is the range of punishment I am facing, including enhancements? A specific range with the statute named
What are the first three things you will do on my case? Concrete actions with a timeline
What is the worst realistic outcome here? An honest answer, even though it is unpleasant

 

If a lawyer will not sit still for the last question, he is going to be a problem later, when the answer matters.

What a former prosecutor knows

I spent years at the Bexar County District Attorney’s Office, including as Chief of the Criminal Trial Division and Chief of the Major Crimes Division. I am not going to pretend that makes me a better lawyer than someone who never worked there. What it gives me is specific and limited: I know how a case gets evaluated inside that building, who has authority to approve what, which weaknesses in a file the State’s own lawyers worry about, and what a chief looks at before deciding whether to try a case or resolve it.

That knowledge shortens the distance between the first phone call and a realistic conversation about where the case is going. It does not change the evidence. Nothing changes the evidence except the evidence.

Warning signs

These are the things that make me uneasy when clients describe a prior consultation.

  • A promise or a prediction of a result. No lawyer can ethically guarantee an outcome, and one who does it in the first meeting will do worse things later.
  • A fee quoted before the lawyer has asked what you are charged with, what your record is, and what county the case is in.
  • Pressure to sign today, or a discount that expires tonight.
  • Website results that are vague about the offense, the county, and the disposition. Specifics are provable. Vagueness usually is not.
  • A lawyer who has not read the probable cause affidavit but already knows the defense.
  • No written fee agreement.

Does the cheapest lawyer cost more?

Sometimes and not always, and anyone who tells you it is a universal rule is selling. Here is the honest version. A criminal case has a fixed amount of work in it that is set by the evidence, not by the fee. Records have to be obtained. Video has to be watched, all of it, in real time. Witnesses have to be found and interviewed before they move. Motions have to be researched and written and argued. If the fee does not support that work, the work does not get done, and nobody tells you which parts were skipped.

Ask what the fee buys in hours and in tasks. It is a fair question and it has a real answer. For how I set fees, see what a criminal defense lawyer costs in San Antonio.

What to bring to the consultation

  • The cause number and the name of the court, if charges have been filed
  • Any bond paperwork and any conditions of release
  • The magistrate’s order for emergency protection, if there is one
  • Any card, letter, or business card left by a detective
  • A written timeline of what happened, in your own words, kept to one page
  • Names and phone numbers of anyone who was present
  • Your criminal history as you remember it, including deferred adjudications and out-of-state matters

Do not bring your phone to the consultation expecting me to look through it, and do not delete anything on it. Deleting is its own problem.

One last thing

You are about to hand a stranger the most important decision of your life and then do what he tells you for the next year. Meet him. Listen to whether he asks you questions or talks at you. Notice whether he tells you something you did not want to hear. That last one is the tell.

If you want to have that conversation with me, call 210-663-3750 . I answer my own phone.

Related reading: what board certification means , my years at the District Attorney’s Office , and where I practice .

Call Mario: 210-663-3750